How to Choose the Right Pruning Tool for Your Garden Jobs

The Right Pruning Tool for the Job

If you’ve ever struggled with the wrong pruning tool, you know what it’s like. The blades don’t fit the branch and, after wrestling to cut it, the plant is damaged and your hands ache. Guilty as charged! 

With the right hand pruners, you should be able to get a nice, crisp cuts and clean slices—easily and readily— without any collateral damage to the plants or you!

I’m using Fiskars tools as the examples in this post. I’m a long-time fan of their products and, to prepare this post, I contacted Fiskars and requested sample tools to test.

Gardening on a Budget

If you’ve been reading Empress of Dirt for a while, you know I’m a true frugalista (How I created my first dream garden on $100 per year), originally out of necessity and eventually by choice.

When it comes to garden tools, I do not want many, just good quality tools that are long-lasting and get the job done.

Cheap tools are not just frustrating to use (and sometimes dangerous or harmful), but wasteful as well. I can buy one really good quality shovel that will outlast me, or cheaper new ones every few years, adding up to more far more than the cost of the good one.

So, if you can, forgo that dollar store pruner and opt for something that will serve you for many years.

Which Pruners Do I Need?

Pruning Dictionary
Here’s a quick primer in speaking Prunish (I just made that up).

• Pruners are one-handed cutting tools intended for smaller cuts.
• Loppers require two hands to operate them and work on medium size cuts.
• Pruning saws are one-handed (like workshop saws) and intended for larger cuts.

You might also notice the words anvil, bypass, and ratchet mentioned.

• Anvil = a single cutting blade that closes down on a flat surface (the anvil).
• Bypass = blades that do just that: bypass each other. There’s usually one sharp blade and one dull one. These are often stronger than anvil pruners.
• Ratchet = amped-up anvil pruners, adding some extra leverage to assist your hands. These are often the strongest and most expensive pruners.

Choosing Pruners

There is not a single type of pruner to fit all situations. And, as mentioned at the start, if you try to make one tool work for all cuts, you will injure both the plant/tree, the tool, and perhaps yourself (by forcing the tool to do things it’s not made to do).

If you’re just needing a pruner for a small one-time job, try to borrow one. If you’re needing pruners for ongoing garden maintenance, you’ll probably only need a few different ones to keep everything pruned, primped, and healthy.

Questions to Answer
1. What are you cutting? Flowers? Grasses? Vines? Shrubs? Branches? 
2. How big are the largest branches (in diameter)? Choose pruners, loppers, and pruning saws based on this cutting measurement.
3. How tough is it to cut? Pruners and loppers are usually enough, but really tough jobs may require ratchet pruners, or saws.
4. Can you reach it from the ground or is it up in a tree? Never prune anything overhead! If you need help reaching, find the right tool (or person) for the job.
5. Do you have any strength or mobility issues with your hands or arms (arthritis, carpel tunnel, etc.)? If so, look for lighter weight tools with soft grip handles (where available).

Features to Look For

• Feels good in your hands, designed to reduce blistering, not too heavy (doesn’t strain lower arms).
• Right cutting capacity – be sure the maximum cutting size is right for the job (inches in diameter).
• No-stick blades.
• Lock for blades when not in use.
• Warranty against defects.

Pick Your Pruner Based on the Job

Stems and Small Branches

Choose pruners for branches up to ¾” in diameter.

• Powergear2 pruner (these are the ones I use all the time)
• Heavy Duty Ratchet Pruner (for hard-to-cut small branches)

Branches too high to reach? The extendable pruner/saw extends from 7 to 16-feet long.

Thick and High Branches

Choose long handle loppers by branch size.
The longer the loppers, the larger the cut size.

This is the tool I use for fruit trees.

• PowerGear2 Lopper (18”) cuts branches up to 1 1/2” in diameter.
• PowerGear2 Lopper (32”) cuts branches up to 2” in diameter.

Need to trim high-up branches? This extendable pruner/saw reaches 16 feet.

Hedges and Shrubs

Choose hedge shears.
Consider the weight of the tool for comfort, but also the reach.

• PowerGear Hedge Shear (23″)
• Sculpting Hedge Shear (18”) If you just have small jobs, pick a shorter, lighter pair.

Flowers, Plants, and Herbs

If you have a kitchen garden and cut herbs for dinner each night (or do other fine cutting), fine small snips are great.

• Softtouch Micro-Tip Pruning Snips are just 6” long and really easy on the hands.

Trimming Around Flower Beds, Trees, Sidewalks

Good trimming in a garden is a game changer! I love crisp edges around the garden beds. It gives the garden a really polished look.
I used to use a serrated kitchen knife (which works quite well).

More options:

• Grass Shear (pick according to size you want). Grass has a tendency to stick to blades and get jammed. Look for no-stick coating on blades.
• Billhook Saw works great for digging in and cutting up deep roots including overgrown grass (that has crept into the garden beds).

Vines, Shoots, Suckers, Ornamental Grasses, Old Perennial Growth

When I’m clearing up all the old perennial growth (flowers and grasses) in the spring, I like a machete-like cutting tool.

Billhooks are an excellent option. It’s a one-handed tool making it easy to grab the plants, chop them down, and move on. Much faster than using two-handed shears.

• Billhook Saw – This has a two-sided blade (slices and saws) so it’s super handy for any quick cuts like chopping off shoots and suckers and dividing perennials.

Twine, Wire, Beer Bottle Caps, Garden Art Making

I use scissors all the time in the garden. I finally found some that are all-purpose.

• Cuts + More Titanium All Purpose Scissors– cuts paper, plastic, twine, light rope, and wire. Also has pointed awl tips and bottle opener. You can take it apart and use the blades as knives. The whole unit is dishwasher safe.

Useful? Share it!
If you are now fluent in Prunish, please share the good news!

~Melissa the Empress of Dirt ♛

Next

• How to Safely Prune Hard-to-Reach Tree Branches | This tool is awesome
• 7 Weeding Tips Every Gardener Should Know | These make it faster and easier
• Jump-Start Your Spring Garden in Fall | You’ll thank yourself later
• What to Prune in Fall and What Should Wait | Plus, how to pick the right tools for the job

---

Seed Starting for Beginners | Ebook

$7.99 US | Instant Download

Add to Cart

Complete guide to indoor seed starting. Grow your own garden!
See contents ->

---